Leeham News and Analysis
There's more to real news than a news release.
This week Boeing must deliver on safety–again
By the Leeham News Team
Analysis
May 28, 2024, © Leeham News: Boeing’s FAA-mandated plan to improve its safety culture is due this week.
Following the Jan. 5 accident involving Alaska Airlines Flight 1282 and a year-long safety study commissioned by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), Boeing was given 90 days to come up with a new plan to improve safety procedures.
Boeing’s been down this path before. Following the 2018/19 crashes of two 737-8 MAXes in which 346 people died, Boeing implemented several safety studies and procedures. Flight 1282 demonstrated a shocking lack of results from the earlier efforts.
The FAA on Feb. 29 gave Boeing 90 days to make a realistic plan for addressing the path forward to an acceptable level of quality. This is an exceptionally tall ask given all that has gone wrong in the recent past. It’s unclear if the FAA will release Boeing’s proposal publicly. But LNA’s reporting team, which includes retired Boeing employees whose duties included safety and production, thinks that whatever plan is put forth to the FAA will all boil down to one point, execution. That’s Boeing’s problem today: Failure to execute its production plan as documented in its operation command media.
Big hurdles for COMAC to become serious challenger to Airbus, Boeing
Subscription Required
By Scott Hamilton
May 27, 2024, © Leeham News: A flurry of orders by China’s Big Three airlines finally began to balance announced deals for the COMAC C-919 mainline jet.
Until the recent orders from Air China, China Eastern, and China Southern, the vast number of the announced transactions were concentrated among Chinese lessors. The imbalance was not a good thing.
Airbus and Boeing prefer speculative orders by lessors amounting to 25% to perhaps 35% of the order book. (Lessors in recent decades often accounted for 40% to 50% of the in-service fleet, but the differences were from sale/leasebacks of orders originally placed by airlines.)
Boeing and Airbus have different views toward lessors. Airbus, especially under then-Chief Commercial Officer John Leahy, viewed lessors as an extension of the Airbus marketing arm. Lessors broadened Airbus’ market penetration, especially during the early years of the A320’s entry into service.
On the other hand, Boeing viewed lessors as a necessary evil, preferring to deal with a select few rather than a large number. Both viewed lessors to some degree as competitors to direct sales.
Before the Big Three orders, COMAC’s tally was around 760+ for the C919. More than 70% of the announced orders were for Chinese lessors. No lessor outside China was a customer and only Indonesia’s Trans Nusa (partly owned by Chinese lessor CALC) was a customer outside China.
Following the Big Three orders, about 46% of the orders are from airlines—a much better mix than before but still overweighted with lessors.
With Airbus’ A320 family sold out into the 2030 decade and Boeing’s MAX production and delivery schedules in disarray, what alternatives do customers have to the Big Two OEMs? COMAC is the most likely, but the challenges are immense.
COMAC’s challenges
COMAC has big challenges ahead if it wants to become a major global player in commercial aviation.
- Gaining credibility for the C919 inside and outside China.
- Economic competitiveness to the A320neo and 737 MAX.
- Ramping up production.
- Global product support.
- Geopolitical concerns.
The all-important cabin. Part 1
Subscription required
By Bjorn Fehrm
May 23, 2024, © Leeham News: We will do an article series about the all-important cabin and its seating for an airliner. The cabin layout and its comfort are the most important parts of an airliner for the passenger.
Most of the time, the traveler doesn’t know what type of aircraft he is flying on, but he will have a clear understanding of the cabin and whether it meets his expectations.
The cabin is where the airline can expose its branding and set the flight experience for the passenger. It’s thus an area that is updated to new cabin concepts for the fleet more often today than 10 years ago, especially for mainline carriers.
The cabin is also important in evaluating airliners, as the characteristics of the aircraft (fuel consumption, operational costs) are evaluated per seat. OEMs have become experts in maximizing the seating of their aircraft to gain an advantage during an evaluation. Sometimes, in a non-transparent way. We will explain the typical tricks and how to guarantee an apples-to-apples comparison when evaluating airliners.
Summary:
- The cabin and its seats mean different things to a passenger, airline, and evaluation expert.
- We go through the different priorities, and how they affect the end product.
David Calhoun’s first and last addresses to Boeing shareholders have common themes, four years apart
David Calhoun, president and CEO of The Boeing Co.
May 21, 2024, © Leeham News: David Calhoun was named CEO of The Boeing Co. in December 2019. He assumed office in January 2020. He had been on the Board of Directors since 2009. His first annual shareholders meeting as CEO was the 2020 AGM, for the financial year 2019.
When Calhoun was named CEO, the 737 MAX had been grounded for nine months, following the crashes in October 2018 and March 2019 of the Lion Air and Ethiopian Airlines MAX 8s. There was no end in sight for the grounding—which ultimately lasted 21 months.
Three months after Calhoun assumed office, the global COVID-19 pandemic erupted. Global passenger traffic collapsed and so did deliveries of the widebody aircraft prevalent on international routes. Boeing Commercial Airplanes (BCA) revenues and cash flow, already emasculated by the MAX grounding, was put under further strain. Then, in October 2020, Boeing suspended all deliveries of new 787s after finding production flaws. This suspension lasted 20 months.
Following the January 5, 2024, accident involving Alaska Airlines Flight 1282, a 737-9 MAX, Boeing’s safety record which came under fire in 2018-19 was again called into question. Calhoun announced his retirement effective the end of this year. Other Board-level and executive changes were also announced.
The May 17, 2024, Boeing AGM was Calhoun’s last as CEO. His prepared statement was reminiscent of his first as CEO. Some of the themes—notably about safety—expressed last week were eerily similar to those articulated in 2020 during his first address to shareholders.
LNA has assembled Calhoun’s first and last addresses to shareholders. We’ve highlighted common themes between the two addresses, made four years apart.
Southwest, the “legacy LCC,” part 2: Bloated labor expense, difficult fleet strategy result in uncompetitive cost structure
Subscription Required
Now open to all readers.
By Judson Rollins
Introduction
May 20, 2024, © Leeham News: Southwest Airlines was founded on the principles of high employee productivity and low labor costs. But 53 years after beginning operations, its labor cost as a percentage of expenses — and per seat-mile — is now the highest among US airlines.
Boeing 737 MAXes parked after the 2019 MAX grounding. Source: Getty Images via AFP.
LNA studied Southwest’s and its US competitors’ 2023 annual reports to comprehensively understand their relative profitability. The resulting picture is less than flattering to the Dallas-based carrier. Southwest is increasingly a “legacy LCC,” with LCC-like unit revenue but a legacy cost structure.
Summary
- Labor costs are dramatically worse than legacy or LCC competitors.
- Fleet and route strategy are crimped by overreliance on the Boeing 737.
- Southwest’s insular management team and culture may be its greatest obstacle to business model innovation and continued profitability.
Boeing’s safety, labor battles heat up while CEO will walk with $34m payout
By Scott Hamilton
May 16, 2024, © Leeham News: Even as Boeing is under fire for safety issues, the company’s battles heat up.
- Boeing remains at an impasse with its engineers and technicians union over creating a new safety program. The company has doubled down, the union says. SPEEA has turned to lawyers for legal advice.
- The US Department of Justice on Tuesday notified Boeing that it concluded the company failed to live up to terms of a 2021 Deferred Prosecution Agreement (DPA) intended to put to rest all criminal liabilities stemming from the 2018-19 737 MAX crashes that killed 346 people. DOJ may go ahead with criminal prosecutions now.
- The firefighters union was locked out by Boeing over contract negotiations, bringing in replacement workers. The union says Boeing’s actions threaten safety at its plants. SPEEA and its powerful touch labor union, the IAM 751, are picketing with the firefighters in support.
- IAM 751 apparently is using the firefighters’ strike as a training ground in anticipation of its own possible strike in September when its current contract expires.
A350-1000 or 777-8? Part 2
Subscription required
By Bjorn Fehrm
May 16, 2024, © Leeham News: We are doing an article series comparing the capabilities of the Airbus A350-1000 and the Boeing 777X. We have looked at the A350-1000 versus the 777-9 and started comparing the history and capabilities of the 777-8 versus the A350-1000 last week.
Now, we use our Aircraft Performance and Cost Model (APCM) to fly the aircraft on a typical route and compare their performance.
Summary:
- The A350-1000 and the latest 777-8 definition is a closer payload-range match than the A350-1000 and 777-9.
- Passenger and cargo capabilities are similar. The economic comparison will be determined by maintenance costs for the engines.
Airbus’ A350-1000 or Boeing’s 777-8? Part 1
Subscription required
By Bjorn Fehrm
May 9, 2024, © Leeham News: We are doing an article series comparing the capabilities of the Airbus A350-1000 and the Boeing 777X series. We started with the 777-9, the larger model. Now, we continue with the shorter 777-8, an aircraft closer in size to the A350-1000.
The 777-8 was originally launched in a shorter version together with the 777-9. Then, it went very quiet around the 777-8, with some analysts speculating that the passenger version would not be done. The 777X freighter, the 777-8F, was launched in January 2022. It became a bit longer than the 777-8. This now forms the final definition of the 777-8.
Summary:
- The comparison of the A350-1000 and the 777-8 is comparing the longer-narrower versus the shorter-wider.
- Which is the best? We use Leeham’s Aircraft Performance and Cost Model (APCM) to find out.
Southwest could solve its MAX 7 woes … by buying Breeze?
Subscription Required
Now open to all readers
By Judson Rollins
Introduction
May 6, 2024, © Leeham News: Southwest Airlines, still awaiting the certification and delivery of the Boeing 737 MAX 7 as a replacement for its aging 737-700s, might have an unorthodox alternative: acquire startup Breeze Airways for its Airbus A220 fleet – and, more importantly, its order book.
Source: Orlando International Airport via Simple Flying.
Launched in 2021 by serial airline entrepreneur David Neeleman, Breeze operates 23 A220-300s, 10 Embraer E190s, and six E195s to 47 airports across the US. It focuses on connecting larger airports to smaller cities, including a handful of transcontinental routes.
Ironically, the Utah-based airline achieved its first-ever monthly operating profit in March. It recently announced plans to operate the A220 exclusively by the end of this year.
According to a January update from database provider Cirium, Breeze has between 11 and 13 A220s scheduled for delivery each year through 2028. No options are listed.
Market intelligence says Airbus Commercial Aircraft CEO Christian Scherer visited with Southwest executives in Dallas and Breeze leadership near Salt Lake City in mid-April. This was well after Breeze’s February order for 10 additional A220s.
Summary
- To deliver or not to deliver the MAX 7?
- Southwest’s aging 737-700 fleet has few replacement options
- How a Breeze acquisition might play out
- Azorra Aviation is likely a key partner in helping Southwest get A220s
A350-1000 or 777-9? Part 4
Subscription required
By Bjorn Fehrm
May 2, 2024, © Leeham News: We are doing an article series comparing the capabilities of the Airbus A350-1000 and the Boeing 777-9. We looked at the development history of the aircraft and then their capability and fuel economics.
We could see that the 777-9 is trailing the A350-1000 in payload range, partly because we compare the base version of the 777-9 with a further developed A350-1000. Now, we investigate what the 777-9 performance would be should we include a typical future development of the Maximum TakeOff Weight (MTOW).
Summary:
- The A350-1000 has a clear payload-range advantage over the standard 777-9.
- With an in-service Maximum TakeOff Weight (MTOW) development like the A350-1000, the difference is reduced.